A Connectionist Theory of Phenomenal Experience

O'Brien, Gerard and Opie, Jon (1999) A Connectionist Theory of Phenomenal Experience. [Journal (Paginated)]

Full text available as:

[img] PDF


When cognitive scientists apply computational theory to the problem of phenomenal consciousness, as many of them have been doing recently, there are two fundamentally distinct approaches available. Either consciousness is to be explained in terms of the nature of the representational vehicles the brain deploys; or it is to be explained in terms of the computational processes defined over these vehicles. We call versions of these two approaches vehicle and process theories of consciousness, respectively. However, while there may be space for vehicle theories of consciousness in cognitive science, they are relatively rare. This is because of the influence exerted, on the one hand, by a large body of research which purports to show that the explicit representation of information in the brain and conscious experience are dissociable, and on the other, by the classical computational theory of mind – the theory that takes human cognition to be a species of symbol manipulation. But two recent developments in cognitive science combine to suggest that a reappraisal of this situation is in order. First, a number of theorists have recently been highly critical of the experimental methodologies employed in the dissociation studies – so critical, in fact, it’s no longer reasonable to assume that the dissociability of conscious experience and explicit representation has been adequately demonstrated. Second, classicism, as a theory of human cognition, is no longer as dominant in cognitive science as it once was. It now has a lively competitor in the form of connectionism; and connectionism, unlike classicism, does have the computational resources to support a robust vehicle theory of consciousness. In this paper we develop and defend this connectionist vehicle theory of consciousness. It takes the form of the following simple empirical hypothesis: phenomenal experience consists in the explicit representation of information in neurally realized PDP networks. This hypothesis leads us to re-assess some common wisdom about consciousness, but, we will argue, in fruitful and ultimately plausible ways.

Item Type:Journal (Paginated)
Keywords:connectionism, phenomenal experience, classicism, vehicle theory of consciousness, process theory of consciousness, philosophy of mind, dissociation, mental representation
Subjects:Neuroscience > Computational Neuroscience
Psychology > Cognitive Psychology
Philosophy > Philosophy of Mind
JOURNALS > Behavioral & Brain Sciences
ID Code:1412
Deposited By: Opie, Jon
Deposited On:29 Mar 2001
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:54

Commentary/Response Threads

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Akins, K. (1996) Lost the Plot? Reconstructing Dennett’s Multiple Drafts Theory of Consciousness. Mind

and Language 11: 1-43.

Baars, B.J. (1988) A Cognitive Theory of Consciousness. Cambridge University Press.

Bechtel, W. (1988a) Connectionism and rules and representation systems: Are they compatible?

Philosophical Psychology.1: 1-15.ible ways.

A Connectionst Theory of Phenomenal Experience 36

Bechtel, W. (1988b) Connectionism and interlevel relations. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 11: 24-25.

Bechtel, W. & Abrahamsen, A. (1991) Connectionism and the Mind. Blackwell.

Bisiach, E. (1992) Understanding consciousness: Clues from unilateral neglect and related disorders. In

Milner and Rugg, 1992.

Block, N. (1993) Book review of Dennett’s Consciousness Explained. Journal of Philosophy 90:181-93.

Block, N. (1995) On a confusion about a function of consciousness. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 18:227-87.

Cam, P. (1984) Consciousness and content-formation. Inquiry 27: 381-97.

Campion, J., Latto, R. & Smith, Y.M. (1983) Is blindsight an effect of scattered light, spared cortex, and

near-threshold vision?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 6:423-86

Chalmers, D. (1995) Facing up to the problem of consciousness. Journal of Consciousness Studies 2: 200-19.

Chalmers, D. (1996) The Conscious Mind: In Search of a Fundamental Theory. Oxford University Press.

Charland, L.C. (1995) Emotion as a natural kind: Towards a computational foundation for emotion theory.

Philosophical Psychology 8: 59-84.

Chomsky, N. (1980) Rules and representations. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3: 1-62.

Churchland, P.M. (1995) The Engine of Reason, the Seat of the Soul. MIT Press.

Churchland, P.S. & Sejnowski, T (1992) The Computational Brain. MIT Press.

Clark, A. (1989) Microcognition: Philosophy, Cognitive Science, and Parallel Distributed Processing. MIT


Clark, A. (1993) Associative Engines: Connectionism, Concepts and Representational Change. MIT Press.

Clark, A. & Karmiloff-Smith, A. (1993) The cognizer’s innards: A psychological and philosophical

perspective on the development of thought. Mind and Language 8: 487-519.

Clark, A. & Thornton, C. (forthcoming) Trading spaces: Computation, representation and the limits of

uninformed learning. Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

Cleland, C.E. (1993) Is the Church-Turing thesis true?. Minds and Machines 3: 283-313.

Corteen, R.S. (1986) Electrodermal responses to words in an irrelevant message: A partial reappraisal.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences 9: 27-28.

Corteen, R.S. & Wood, B. (1972) Electrodermal responses to shock-associated words in an unattended

channel. Journal of Experimental Psychology 94: 308-13.

Cottrell, A. (1995) Tertium datur? Reflections on Owen Flanagan’s Consciousness Reconsidered. Philosophical

Psychology 8: 85-103.

Cummins, R. (1986) Inexplicit representation. In: The Representation of Knowledge and Belief, ed. M.Brand

& R.Harnish. University of Arizona Press.

Cummins, R. (1996) Representations, Targets, and Attitudes. MIT Press.

Cummins, R. & Schwarz, G. (1991) Connectionism, computation, and cognition. In: Connectionism and the

Philosophy of Mind, ed. T.Horgan & J.Tienson. Kluwer.

Cussins, A. (1990) The connectionist construction of concepts. In: The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence,

ed. M.Boden. Oxford University Press

Crick, F. (1984) Function of the thalamic reticular complex: The searchlight hypothesis. Proceedings of the

National Academy of Sciences, USA 81: 4586-90.

Dennett, D.C. (1982) Styles of mental representation. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society New Series 83:


Dennett, D.C. (1984) Cognitive wheels: The frame problem of AI. In Minds, Machines and Evolution, ed.

C.Hookway. Cambridge University Press.

Dennett, D.C. (1991) Consciousness Explained. Little Brown.

Dennett, D.C. (1993) The message is: There is no medium. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 53:


Dennett, D.C & Kinsbourne, M. (1992) Time and the observer: The where and when of consciousness in the

brain. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 15:183-247.

Dienes, Z., Broadbent, D.E. & Berry, D. (1991) Implicit and explicit knowledge bases in artificial grammar

learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 17: 875-8.

A Connectionst Theory of Phenomenal Experience 37

Dietrich, E. (1989) Semantics and the computational paradigm in cognitive psychology. Synthese 79: 119-


Dretske, F. (1993) Conscious experience. Mind 102: 263-83.

Dretske, F. (1995) Naturalizing the Mind. MIT Press.

Dulany, D.E. (1991) Conscious representation and thought systems. In: Advances in Social Cognition IV,

ed. R.S.Wyer Jr. & T.K.Srull. Lawrence Erlbaum

Dulany, D.E. (1996) Consciousness in the explicit (deliberative) and implicit (evocative). In: Scientific

Approaches to Consciousness, ed, J.Cohen & J.Schooler. Lawrence Erlbaum

Dulany, D.E., Carlson, R.A. & Dewey, G.I.(1984) A case of syntactical learning and judgement: How

conscious and how abstract? Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 113: 541-55.

Edelman, G.M. (1989) The Remembered Present: A Biological Theory of Consciousness. Basic Books.

Field, H. (1978) Mental representation. Erkenntnis 13: 9-61.

Flanagan, O. (1992) Consciousness Reconsidered. MIT Press.

Fodor, J.A. (1975) The Language of Thought. MIT Press.

Fodor, J.A. (1981) Representations. MIT Press.

Fodor, J.A. (1983) The Modularity of Mind. MIT Press.

Fodor, J.A. (1987) Psychosemantics. MIT Press.

Fodor, J.A. & Pylyshyn, Z.W. (1988) Connectionism and cognitive architecture: A critical analysis.

Cognition 28: 3-71.

Gardenfors, P. (1996) Mental representation, conceptual spaces and metaphors. Synthese 106: 21-47.

Hardin, C.L. (1988) Color for Philosophers. Hackett.

Harman, G. (1973) Thought. Princeton University Press

Hatfield, G. (1991) Representation in perception and cognition: Connectionist affordances. In Philosophy

and Connectionist Theory, ed. W.Ramsey, S.Stich & D.Rumelhart. Lawrence Erlbaum.

Haugeland, J. (1981). Semantic engines: An introduction to mind design. In: Mind Design, ed. J.Haugeland.

MIT Press.

Haugeland, J. (1985) Artificial Intelligence: The Very Idea. MIT Press.

Holender, D. (1986) Semantic activation without conscious awareness in dichotic listening, parafoveal

vision, and visual masking: A survey and appraisal. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 9: 1-66.

Hopcroft, J.E. & Ullman, J.D. (1979) Introduction to Automata Theory, Languages and Computation.

Addison Wesley Publishing Company

Horgan, T. & Tienson, J. (1989) Representations without rules. Philosophical Topics 27: 147-74.

Jackendoff, R. (1987) Consciousness and the Computational Mind. MIT Press.

James, W. (1890) The Principles of Psychology. Holt.

Johnson-Laird, P.N. (1988) The Computer and the Mind: An Introduction to Cognitive Science. Fontana


Johnston, W.A. & Dark, V.J. (1982) In defense of intraperceptual theories of attention. Journal of

Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 8: 407-21.

Johnston, W.A. & Wilson, J. (1980) Perceptual processing of nontargets in an attention task. Memory and

Cognition 8: 372-7

Kinsbourne, M. (1988) Integrated field theory of consciousness. In: Consciousness in Contemporary

Science, ed. A.Marcel & E.Bisiach. Clarendon Press.

Kinsbourne, M. (1995) Models of consciousness: Serial or parallel in the brain? In: The Cognitive

Neurosciences ed. M.Gazzaniga. MIT Press.

Lackner, J.R. & Garrett, M.F. (1972) Resolving ambiguity: Effects of biasing context in the unattended ear.

Cognition 1: 359-72.

Levine, J. (1983) Materialism and qualia: The explanatory gap. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 64: 354-61.

Levine, J. (1993) On leaving out what it is like. In: Consciousness: Psychological and Philosophical Essays,

ed. M.Davies & G.Humphreys. Blackwell.

A Connectionst Theory of Phenomenal Experience 38

Lloyd, D. (1988) Connectionism in the golden age of cognitive science. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 11:


Lloyd, D. (1991) Leaping to conclusions: Connectionism, consciousness, and the computational mind. In:

Connectionism and the Philosophy of Mind, ed.T.Horgan & J.Tienson. Kluwer.

Lloyd, D. (1995) Consciousness: A connectionist manifesto. Minds and Machines 5: 161-85.

Lloyd, D. (1996) Consciousness, connectionism, and cognitive neuroscience: A meeting of the minds.

Philosophical Psychology 9: 61-79.

Mandler, G. (1985) Cognitive Psychology: An Essay in Cognitive Science. Lawrence Erlbaum.

Mangan, B. (1993a) Dennett, consciousness, and the sorrows of functionalism. Consciousness and

Cognition 2: 1-17.

Mangan, B. (1993b) Taking phenomenology seriously: The “fringe” and its implications for cognitive

research. Consciousness and Cognition 2: 89-108.

Mangan, B. (1996) Against functionalism: Consciousness as an information-bearing medium. Presented at

the Tucson II conference on consciousness, Arizona

Marcel, A.J. (1983) Conscious and unconscious perception: Experiments on visual masking and word

recognition. Cognitive Psychology 15: 197-237.

MacKay, D.G. (1973) Aspects of a theory of comprehension, memory and attention. Quarterly Journal of

Experimental Psychology 25:22-40

McClelland, J.L. & Rumelhart, D.E., eds. (1986) Parallel Distributed Processing: Explorations in the

Microstructure of Cognition Vol. 2: Psychological and Biological Models. MIT Press.

Milner, A. & Rugg, M., eds. (1992) The Neuropsychology of Consciousness. Academic Press.

Nagel, T. (1974). What is it like to be a bat? Philosophical Review 83: 435-50.

Nelson, T.O. (1978) Detecting small amounts of information in memory: Savings for nonrecognized items.

Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 4: 453-68

Newman, J. (1995) Thalamic contributions to attention and consciousness. Consciousness and Cognition 4:


Newell, A. (1980) Physical symbol systems. Cognitive Science 4: 135-83.

Newstead, S.E. & Dennis, I. (1979) Lexical and grammatical processing of unshadowed messages: A

reexamination of the MacKay effect. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 31: 477-88

Nolan, K.A. & Caramazza, A. (1982) Unconscious perception of meaning: A failure to replicate. Bulletin of

the Psychonomic Society 20: 23-6.

O’Brien, G. (1993) The connectionist vindication of folk psychology. In: Folk Psychology and the

Philosophy of Mind, ed. S.Christensen & D.Turner. Lawrence Erlbaum.

Palmer, S. (1978) Fundamental aspects of cognitive representation. In: Cognition and Categorization, ed.

E.Rosch & B.Lloyd. Lawrence Erlbaum.

Penrose, R. (1989) The Emperor’s New Mind. Penguin Books

Perenin, M.T. (1978) Visual function within the hemianopic field following early cerebral hemidecortication

in man. II. Pattern discrimination. Neuropsychologia 16: 697-708.

Perenin, M.T. & Jeannerod, M. (1975) Residual vision in cortically blind hemifields. Neuropsychologia 13:


Perruchet, P. & Pacteau, C. (1990) Synthetic grammar learning: Implicit rule abstraction or explicit

fragmentary knowledge? Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 119: 264-75.

Purcell, D.G., Stewart, A.L. & Stanovich, K.K. (1983) Another look at semantic priming without awareness.

Perception and Psychophysics 34: 65-71.

Pylyshyn, Z.W. (1980) Computation and cognition: Issues in the foundations of cognitive science.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3: 111-69.

Pylyshyn, Z.W (1984) Computation and Cognition. MIT Press.

Pylyshyn, Z.W. (1989) Computing in cognitive science. In: Foundations of Cognitive Science, ed. M.Posner.

MIT Press

Ramsey, W., Stich, S. & Rumelhart, D.E., eds. (1991) Philosophy and Connectionist Theory. Lawrence


A Connectionst Theory of Phenomenal Experience 39

Reber, A.S. (1967) Implicit learning of artificial grammars. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior

5: 855-63.

Rey, G. (1992) Sensational sentences. In: Consciousness: Psychological and Philosophical Essays, ed.

M.Davies & G.Humphreys. Blackwell.

Rubel, L.A. (1989) Digital simulation of analog computation and Church’s thesis. Journal of Symbolic Logic

54: 1011-7.

Rumelhart, D.E. (1989) The architecture of mind: A connectionist approach. In: Foundations of Cognitive

Science, ed. M. Posner. MIT Press.

Rumelhart, D.E. & McClelland, J.L., eds. (1986) Parallel Distributed Processing: Explorations in the

Microstructure of Cognition Vol 1: Foundations. MIT Press.

Rumelhart, D.E., Smolensky, P., McClelland, J.L. & Hinton, G.E. (1986) Schemata and sequential thought

processes in PDP models. In McClelland & Rumelhart 1986.

Sacks, O. (1985) The Man Who Mistook His Wife For a Hat. Picador.

Schacter, D. (1989) On the relation between memory and consciousness: Dissociable interactions and

conscious experience. In: Varieties of Memory and Consciousness: Essays in Honour of Endel

Tulving, ed. H.Roediger & F.Craik. Erlbaum.

Schwartz, N. (1990) Feelings and information: Informational and motivational functions of affective states.

In: Handbook of Motivation and Cognition: Foundations of Social Behaviour, ed. R.Sorrentino &

E.Higgins. Guilford Press.

Searle, J.R. (1983) Intentionality. Cambridge University Press

Sejnowski, T.J. (1986) Open questions about computation in cerebral cortex. In: McClelland & Rumelhart


Sejnowski, T.J. & Rosenberg, C. (1987) Paralled networks that learn to pronounce English text. Complex

Systems 1: 145-68.

Shallice, T. (1988a) From Neuropsychology to Mental Structure. Cambridge University Press.

Shallice, T. (1988b) Information-processing models of consciousness: Possibilities and problems. In:

Consciousness in Contemporary Science, ed. A.Marcel & E.Bisiach. Clarendon Press.

Shanks, D.R. & St. John, M.F. (1994) Characteristics of dissociable human learning systems. Behavioral and

Brain Sciences 17:367-447

Smolensky, P. (1988) On the proper treatment of connectionism. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 11: 1-23.

Smolensky, P. (1987). The constituent structure of connectionist mental states: A reply to Fodor and

Pylyshyn. Southern Journal of Philosophy 26(Supplement): 137-61.

Swoyer, C. (1991) Structural representation and surrogative reasoning. Synthese, 87: 449-508.

Sterelny, K. (1990) The Representational Theory of Mind. Blackwell

Strawson, G. (1994) Mental Reality. MIT Press

Tienson, J.L. (1987) An introduction to connectionism. The Southern Journal of Philosophy 26(Supplement):


Tye, M. (1992) Visual qualia and visual content. In: The Contents of Experience, ed. T.Crane. Cambridge

University Press.

Tye, M. (1996) The function of consciousness. Nous 30: 287-305.

Tye, M. (forthcoming) A representational theory of pains and their phenomenal character. In: Essays on

Consciousness, ed. N.Block, O.Flanagan, & G.Guveldere. MIT Press.

Umilta, C. (1988) The control operations of consciousness. In: Consciousness in Contemporary Science, ed.

A.Marcel & E.Bisiach. Clarendon Press.

Van Gelder, T. (1990) Compositionality: A connectionist variation on a classical theme. Cognitive Science

14: 355-84

Van Gulick, R. (1993) Understanding the phenomenal mind: Are we all just armadillos? In: Consciousness:

Psychological and Philosophical Essays, ed. M.Davies & G.Humphreys. Blackwell.

Von Eckardt, B. (1993) What is Cognitive Science? MIT Press.

Weiskrantz, L. (1980) Varieties of residual experience. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 32:


A Connectionst Theory of Phenomenal Experience 40

Weiskrantz, L. (1986) Blindsight: A Case Study and Implications. Clarendon Press.

Weiskrantz, L., Warrington, E., Sanders, M. & Marshall, J. (1974) Visual capacity in the hemianopic field

following a restricted occipital ablation. Brain 97: 709-28.

Zeki, S. (1993) A Vision of the Brain. Blackwell.


Repository Staff Only: item control page