Talking past each other: Making Sense of the Debate over Electronic Publication

Solomon, David J. (2002) Talking past each other: Making Sense of the Debate over Electronic Publication. [Journal (On-line/Unpaginated)]

This is the latest version of this eprint.

Full text available as:

[img] HTML


This paper discusses the implications electronic dissemination for the peer-reviewed serial publication system. To make sense of this complex issue, it is helpful to view it from the perspective of the origins of the system and its three core functions, the ranking of scholarship, facilitating interactive communication among scholars, and creating a comprehensive archive of scholarly and scientific knowledge. Each of these core functions has different requirements that are to some extent overlapping but also to some extent in conflict. The Internet opens the possibility of developing a variety of different models of scholarly communication each fulfilling to a greater or lesser extent these three roles paper journals have served and possibly other roles that were not even conceivable prior to the development of world-wide electronic networks. The implications of electronic distribution for ownership and access to the scholarly literature are profound and likely to exacerbate the already serious serial pricing crisis that is hindering the widespread access to scientific and scholarly information. The scholarly community, which both authors the material contained in these publications and largely consumes the finish product holds the key to solving this crisis and allowing the Internet to be a vehicle for facilitating the dissemination of publicly funded research and scholarship rather than resulting in its transfer to private ownership.

Item Type:Journal (On-line/Unpaginated)
Keywords:Electronic publication, copyright, serial pricing crisis, communication of researc
Subjects:Electronic Publishing > Archives
ID Code:2426
Deposited By: David, Solomon
Deposited On:27 Aug 2002
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:54

Available Versions of this Item

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Burbules NC and Bruce BC, 1995 “This is not a Paper,” Ed Researcher, volume 24, number 8, pp.12-8.

Bloom FE, 1998 The Rightness of Copyright, Science volume 281 pp. 1451.

Guédon J, “In Oldenburg’s Long Shadow: Librarians, Research Scientists, Publishers, and the Control of Scientific Publishing”, Presentation to the May 2001 meeting of the Association of Research Libraries (ARL),, access 30 March 2002.

Harnad S., 1997, “The Paper House of Cards” Ariadne volumne 8, accessed 30 May 2002.

Hipps K., 1999 “Update on Scholarly Publisher Profits”, A Bimonthly Report on Research Library Issues and Actions from ARL, CNI, and SPARC. (207) December (01 June 2002).

Kirkpatick DD., 2000 “As publishers perish, libraries feel the pain”, New York Times, November 3, 2000.

Martin J., Coleman D., 2002 “The archive as an ecosystem” Journal of Electronic Publishing volume 7 number 3, accessed 15 June 2002.

Odlyzko AM. 1999 “Competition and Cooperation: Libraries and Publishers in the Transition to Electronic Scholarly Journals” Journal of Electronic Publishing volume 4 number 4 accessed 2002.

Okerson A 2001, “What price “free”?” Nature Web Debates, access 01 June 2002.

Solomon DJ., 1999 “Is it time to take the paper out of serial publication?” Medical Education Online volume 4 number 7, accessed 16 May 2002.

Sosteric, M., Shi Y., Wenker O., 2001 The upcoming revolution in the scholarly communication system. The Journal of Electronic Publishing volume 7 number 2, accessed 30 March 2002.

Van de Sompel H, Lagoze C., 2000 “The Santa Fe Convention of the Open Archives Initiative” D-Lib Magazine volume 6 issue 2 accessed 20 May 2002.

Van Orsdel L, Born K , 2002 “Periodicals Price Survey 2002: Doing the Digital Flip” Library Journal accessed 20 April 2002,

Varmus H. 1999 “Original proposal for E-biomed (Draft and Addendum) E-BIOMED: A proposal for electronic publications in the biomedical sciences" accessed 30 March 2002.

White R., 2002 “Overview of current issues at NIH” Proceedings from the NIH Regional Seminar April Lansing, Michigan.

Willinsky, J., 2000 “Proposing a knowledge exchange model for scholarly publishing.” Current Issues in Education volume 3, number 6. accessed 20 May 2002.

Willinsky, J, Wolfson L., 2001 The Indexing of Scholarly Journals: A Tipping Point for Publishing Reform? The Journal of Electronic Publishing volume 7 number 2 accessed 20 May 2002.


Repository Staff Only: item control page