Time and the Observer

Dennett, Daniel C and Marcel, Kinsbourne (1992) Time and the Observer. [Journal (Paginated)]

Full text available as:

[img] HTML


Two models of consciousness are contrasted with regard to their treatment of subjective timing. The standard Cartesian Theater model postulates a place in the brain where "it all comes together": where the discriminations in all modalities are somehow put into registration and "presented" for subjective judgment. In particular, the Cartesian Theater model implies that the temporal properties of the content-bearing events occurring within this privileged representational medium determine subjective order. The alternative, Multiple Drafts model holds that whereas the brain events that discriminate various perceptual contents are distributed in both space and time in the brain, and whereas the temporal properties of these various events are determinate, none of these temporal properties determine subjective order, since there is no single, constitutive "stream of consciousness" but rather a parallel stream of conflicting and continuously revised contents. Four puzzling phenomena that resist explanation by the standard model are analyzed: two results claimed by Libet, an apparent motion phenomenon involving color change (Kolers and von Grunau), and the "cutaneous rabbit" (Geldard and Sherrick) an illusion of evenly spaced series of "hops" produced by two or more widely spaced series of taps delivered to the skin. The unexamined assumptions that have always made the Cartesian Theater model so attractive are exposed and dismantled. The Multiple Drafts model provides a better account of the puzzling phenomena, avoiding the scientific and metaphysical extravagances of the Cartesian Theater.

Item Type:Journal (Paginated)
Subjects:Philosophy > Philosophy of Mind
Philosophy > Logic
JOURNALS > Behavioral & Brain Sciences
ID Code:264
Deposited By: Dennett, Daniel
Deposited On:14 Apr 1998
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:53

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Allport, A., 1988, "What Concept of Consciousness?" in Marcel and Bisiach, 1988, pp. 159-82.

Barlow, H. B., and Levick, W. R., 1965, "Mechanisms of pattern selectivity in retina," Journal of Physiology, 178, 477.

Bisiach, E., 1988, "The Haunted Brain and Consciousness," in Marcel and Bisiach, Consciousness in Contemporary Science, Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 101-20.

Blakemore, C., 1976, Mechanics of the Mind, Cambridge Univ. Press.

Breitmeyer, B. G., 1984, Visual Masking, Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Breitmeyer, B. G., 1985, "Problems with the psychophysics of intention," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8, p.539-40.

Bridgeman, B., 1985, "Free Will and the functions of consciousness," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8, p.540.

Calvin, W., 1990, The Cerebral Symphony: Seashore Reflections on the Structure of Consciousness, New York: Bantam Churchland, P. S., 1981, "On the alleged backwards referral of experiences and its relevance to the mind-body problem," Philosophy of Science, 48, pp.165-181.

Churchland, P. S., 1981b, "The timing of sensations: reply to Libet," Philosophy of Science, 48, pp.492-97.

Crick, F. and Koch, C., 1990, "Towards a Neurobiological Theory of Consciousness," in A. R. Damasio, ed., Seminars in the Neurosciences, Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders, pp.263-75.

Danto, A. 1985, "Consciousness and motor control," Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 8, p.540-41.

Dennett, D. C. 1975, "Are Dreams Experiences?" Phil. Review, 73, 151-71.

Dennett, D. C., 1978, "Skinner Skinned," ch. 4 (pp. 53-70), in D. C. Dennett, Brainstorms: Philosophical Essays on Mind and Psychology, Montgomery, VT: Bradford Books.

Dennett, D. C., 1979, review of Popper and Eccles 1977, J.Phil., p.91-97.

Dennett, D. C., 1982, "How to study human consciousness empirically," Synthese, 53, pp.159-80. Dennett, D. C., forthcoming, Consciousness Explained, Boston: Little, Brown.

de l'Homme, Paris.

Dixon, N. F. 1986, "On Private Events and Brain Events," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 9,pp29-30.

Eccles, J. C., 1985, "Mental summation: the timing of voluntary intentions by cortical activity," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8, p. 542-3.

Efron, R., 1967, "The duration of the present," Proc NY Acad Sci., 138, pp 713-29.

Erdelyi, M. H., 1986, "Experimental Indeterminacies in the Dissociation Paradigm of Subliminal Perception," Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 9, pp.30-31.

Farrell, B. A., 1950, "Experience," Mind, 59, pp. 170-98

Gallistel, C. R., 1990, The Organization of Learning, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Geldard, F.A., 1977, "Cutaneous stimuli, vibratory and saltatory," Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 69, pp.83-87. Geldard, F.A., and Sherrick, C.E., 1972, "The Cutaneous 'rabbit': a perceptual illusion," Science, 178, pp.178-9.

Geldard, F.A., and Sherrick, C. E., 1983,"The cutaneous saltatory area and its presumed neural base," Perception and Psychophysics, 33, pp.299-304.

Geldard, F.A., and Sherrick, C. E., 1986, "Space, Time and Touch," Scientific American, 254, pp.90-95.

Gide, A., 1948, Journal des Faux Monnayeurs, Paris: Gallimard

Glynn, I. M., 1990, "Consciousness and Time," Nature, 348, p.477- 79.

Goodman, N., 1978, Ways of Worldmaking, Hassocks, Sussex: Harvester.

Grey Walter, W., 1963, presentation to the Ostler Society, Oxford University.

Harnad, S., 1982, "Consciousness: an Afterthought," Cognition and Brain Theory, 5, pp.29-47

Harnad, S., 1989, "Editorial commentary," Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 12, p. 183. Harnad, S., (unpublished), "Conscious events cannot be localized in time."

Hawking, S., 1988, A Brief History of Time, New York: Bantam.

Hoffman, R. E., and Kravitz, R. E., 1987, "Feedforward action regulation and the experience of will," Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 10, p.782-3.

Holender, D., 1986, "Semantic Activation without Conscious Identification," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 9,pp.1-66.

Honderich, T. 1984, "The time of a conscious sensory experience and mind-brain theories," J. Theoretical Biology, 110, p.115-29.

Hoy, R. C., 1982, "Ambiguities in the Subjective Timing of Experiences Debate," Philosophy of Science, 49, pp.254-62.

Jasper, H. H., 1985, "Brain mechanisms of conscious experience and voluntary action," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8, pp.543- 4.

Julesz, B, 1971, Foundations of Cyclopean Perception, Chicago: Univ of Chicago Press.

Jung, R., 1985, "Voluntary intention and conscious selection in complex learned action," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8, pp. 544-5.

Kinsbourne, M., 1988, "Integrated Field Theory of Consciousness," in A. J. Marcel and E. Bisiach, eds., Consciousness in Contemporary Science, Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.

Kolers, P. A., 1972, Aspects of Motion Perception, London: Pergamon Press.

Kolers, P. and von Grnau, M., 1976, "Shape and color in apparent motion," Vision Research, 16, pp.329-35.

Latto, R., 1985, "Consciousness as an experimental variable: problems of definition, practice, and interpretation," Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 8, pp.545-6

Libermann, A. M., 1970, "The Grammar of Speech and Language," Cognitive Psychology, 1, pp.301-323.

Libet, B., 1965, "Cortical activation in conscious and unconscious experience," Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 9, pp. 77-86.

Libet, B., Wright, E.W., Feinstein, B., and Pearl, D. K., 1979, "Subjective referral of the timing for a conscious sensory experience," Brain, 102, pp.193-224.

Libet, B., 1981, "The experimental evidence for subjective referral of a sensory experience backwards in time: reply to P. S. Churchland," Philosophy of Science, 48, pp.182-97.

Libet, B., 1982, "Brain stimulation in the study of neuronal functions for conscious sensory experiences," Human Neurobiology, 1, 235-42.

Libet, B., 1985, "Unconscious cerebral initiative and the role of conscious will in voluntary action," Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 8, p529-566.

Libet, B., 1985b, "Subjective antedating of a sensory experience and mind-brain theories: reply to Honderich," J.Theoretical Biology, 114, p.563-70.

Libet, B., 1987, "Are the mental experiences of will and self- control significant for the performance of a voluntary act?" Behavioral and Brain Sciences 10, p.783-786.

Libet, B., 1989, "The timing of a subjective experience," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 12, p.183-85.

MacKay, D. M., 1985, "Do we 'control' our brains?" Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 8, p[.546-7.

Marcel, A. J., 1983, "Conscious and Unconscious Perception: An Approach to the Relations between Phenomenal Experience and Perceptual Processes," Cognitive Psychology, 15, pp.238-300.

Marcel, A. J., 1986, "Consciousness and Processing: Choosing and Testing a Null Hypothesis," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 9,pp 40-41.

Mellor, H., 1981, Real Time, Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.

Merikle, P M. and Cheesman, J., 1986, "Consciousness is a 'Subjective' State," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 9, p42.

Minsky, M., 1985, The Society of Minds, New York: Simon and Schuster.

Nagel, T., 1974, "What is it like to be a bat?" Phil. Review, 83,, pp.435-445.

Neisser, U. 1967, Cognitive Psychology, New York: Appleton- Century-Crofts.

Neisser, U., 1981, "John Dean's memory: a case study," Cognition, 9, pp.1-22. Neumann, O., 1990, "Some aspects of phenomenal consciousness and their possible functional correlates," presented at the conference, "The phenomenal mind - how is it possible and why is it necessary?" Center for Interdisciplinary Research (ZiF), Bielefeld, May 14-17, 1990.

Newell, A., Rosenbloom, P. S., and Laird, J. E., 1989, "Symbolic Architectures for Cognition," in M. Posner, ed., Foundations of Cognitive Science, MIT Press, pp.93-132.

Pagels, H., 1988, The Dreams of Reason, New York: Simon & Schuster.

Penfield, W., and Jasper, H., 1954, Epilepsy and the Functional Anatomy of the Human Brain, Boston: Little Brown.

Penrose, R., 1989, The Emperor's New Mind: Concerning computers, minds, and the laws of physics, Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.

Pppel, E., 1985, Grenzen des Bewusstseins, Stuttgart: Deutsche Verlags-Anstal, translated as Mindworks: Time and Conscious Experience, New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1988.

Popper, K R. and Eccles, J.C., 1977, The Self and Its Brain, Berlin: Springer-Verlag.

Pylyshyn, Z., 1979, "Do mental events have durations?" Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2, pp.277-8.

Reingold, E. M., and Merikle, P. M., 1990, "On the Inter- relatedness of Theory and Measurement in the Study of Unconscious Processes," Mind and Language, 5, pp. 9-28.

Ringo, J. L., 1985, "Timing volition: questions of what and when about W," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8, pp.550-51.

Ryle, G., 1949, The Concept of Mind, London: Hutchison

Salter, D., 1989, "Voluntary process and the readiness potential: asking the right questions," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 12, pp. 181-2.

Sarris, V., 1989, "Max Wertheimer on seen motion: theory and evidence," Psychological Research, 51, pp.58-68.

ant, Paris: Gallimard.

Snyder, D. M., 1988, "On the time of a conscious peripheral sensation," J. Theoretical Biology, 130, 253-54.

Sperling, G. 1960, "The Information available in brief visual presentations," Psychological Monographs, 74, No. 11, Stamm, J. S., 1985, "The uncertainty principle in psychology," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8, p.553-4.

Uttal, W. R., 1979, "Do central nonlinearities exist?" Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2, p.286.

Van der Waals, H. G., and Roelofs, C. O., 1930, "Optische Scheinbewegung," Zeitschrift fr Psychologie und Physiologie des Sinnesorgane, 114, pp.241-88, (1931) 115, pp.91-190.

Velmans, M., 1991, "Is Human Information Processing Conscious?" Behavioral and Brain Sciences

Vendler, Z., 1972, Res Cogitans, Cornell: Cornell Univ. Press.

Vendler, Z., 19784, The Matter of Minds, Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Welch, R. B., 1978, Perceptual Modification: Adapting to Altered Sensory Environments, New York: Academic Press.

Wasserman, G. S. and Kong, K-L, 1979, "Absolute Timing of Mental Activities," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2, pp.243-304

Wasserman, G. S., 1985, "Neural/mental chronometry and chronotheology," Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8, p.556-60.

Wertheimer, M. 1912, "Experimentelle Studien ber das Sehen von Bewegung," Zeitschrift fr Psychologie, 61, pp.161-265.


Repository Staff Only: item control page