---
abstract: |-
Searle's celebrated Chinese Room Argument has shaken the
foundations of Artificial Intelligence. Many refutations have been attempted, but
none seem convincing. This paper is an attempt to sort out explicitly the
assumptions and the logical, methodological and empirical points of disagreement.
Searle is shown to have underestimated some features of computer modeling, but
the heart of the issue turns out to be an empirical question about the scope and
limits of the purely symbolic (computational) model of the mind. Nonsymbolic
modeling turns out to be immune to the Chinese Room Argument. The issues
discussed include the Total Turing Test, modularity, neural modeling, robotics,
causality and the symbol-grounding problem.
altloc: []
chapter: ~
commentary: ~
commref: ~
confdates: ~
conference: ~
confloc: ~
contact_email: ~
creators_id: []
creators_name:
- family: Harnad
given: Stevan
honourific: ''
lineage: ''
date: 1989
date_type: published
datestamp: 2001-06-18
department: ~
dir: disk0/00/00/15/73
edit_lock_since: ~
edit_lock_until: ~
edit_lock_user: ~
editors_id: []
editors_name: []
eprint_status: archive
eprintid: 1573
fileinfo: /style/images/fileicons/text_html.png;/1573/1/harnad89.searle.html
full_text_status: public
importid: ~
institution: ~
isbn: ~
ispublished: pub
issn: ~
item_issues_comment: []
item_issues_count: 0
item_issues_description: []
item_issues_id: []
item_issues_reported_by: []
item_issues_resolved_by: []
item_issues_status: []
item_issues_timestamp: []
item_issues_type: []
keywords: 'computation, cognition, Turing Test, Chinese Room Argument, symbol grounding, categorisation, consciousness, transduction, sensorimotor processes, artificial intelligence, neural nets, Total Turing Test, modularity, neural modeling, robotics, causality, symbol-grounding problem'
lastmod: 2011-03-11 08:54:40
latitude: ~
longitude: ~
metadata_visibility: show
note: ~
number: ~
pagerange: 5-25
pubdom: FALSE
publication: Journal of Theoretical and Experimental Artificial Intelligence
publisher: ~
refereed: TRUE
referencetext: |-
Abelson, R.P. (1980) Searle's argument is just a set of Chinese symbols.
Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3: 424-425.
Block, N. (1980) What intuitions about homunculi don't show. Behavioral and
Brain Sciences 3: 425-426.
Carleton, L. (1984) Programs, language understanding and Searle. Synthese 59:
219-230.
Chomsky, N. (1980) Rules and representations. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3:
1-62.
Dennett, D. C. (1978) Why not the whole iguana? Behavioral and Brain Sciences
1: 103-104.
Dennett D. C. (1981) Where am I? In: Hofstadter, D. R. & Dennett, D. C. The
mind's I: Fantasies and reflections on mind and soul New York: Basic Books, pp.
217-229.
Dennett, D.C. (1982) The myth of the computer: An exchange. N.Y. Review
Books: XXIX (11): 56.
Donchin, E. (Ed.) (forthcoming) Proceedings of the 2nd Carmel Conference on
Philosophical Aspects of Event-Related Potentials.
Edelson, T. (1982) Simulating understanding: Making the example fit the question.
Behavioral and Brain Sciences 5: 338-339.
Fodor, J.A. (1975) The language of thought . N.Y.: T.Y. Crowell.
Fodor, J.A. (1980) Methodological solipsism considered as a research strategy in
cognitive psychology. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3: 63-109.
Fodor, J. A. (1981) RePresentations. Cambridge MA: MIT/Bradford.
Fodor, J. A. (1985) Précis of The Modularity of Mind. Behavioral and Brain
Sciences 8: 1-42.
Geschwind, N. (1965) Disconnection syndromes in animals and man. Brain: 88:
237-295; 585-644.
Groeger, J.A. (1987) Computation - the final metaphor? An interview with Philip
Johnson-Laird. New Ideas in Psychology 5: 295-304.
Hanna, P. (1985) Causal powers and cognition. Mind XCIV: 53-63.
Harnad, S. R., Steklis, H.D. & Lancaster, J. B. (Eds.) (1976) Origins and evolution
of language and speech. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 280.
Harnad, S. (1976) Induction, evolution and accountability. Annals of the N.Y.
Academy of Sciences 280: 58-60.
Harnad, S. (1982a) Neoconstructivism: A unifying theme for the cognitive sciences.
In: T.W. Simon & R.J. Scholes (Eds.), Language, mind and brain Hillsdale, N.J.:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, pp. 1-11.
Harnad, S. (1982b) Consciousness: An afterthought. Cognition and Brain Theory
5: 29-47.
Harnad S. (1984) Verifying machines' minds. Contemporary Psychology 29:
389-391.
Harnad, S. (1987a) Psychophysical and cognitive aspects of categorical perception:
A critical overview. In: Categorical perception: The groundwork of cognition (S.
Harnad, Ed.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 1-25.
Harnad, S. (1987b) Category induction and representation. In: Categorical
perception: The groundwork of cognition (S. Harnad, Ed.) Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, pp. 535-565.
Harnad S. (Ed.) (1987c)
Categorical perception: The groundwork of cognition.
NY: Cambridge University Press.
Harvey, R. J. (1985) On the nature of programs, simulations and organisms.
Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8: 741-2.
Hoyle, G. (1984) The scope of neuroethology. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 7:
367-412.
Hubel, D.H. & Wiesel, T.N. (1965) Receptive fields and functional architecture in
two nosntriate areas (18 and 19) of the cat. Journal of Neurophysiology 28:
229-289. Katz, J.J. (1976) Effability: A hypothesis about the uniqueness of natural
language. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 280: 33-41.
Lieblich, I. & Arbib, M.A. (1982) Multiple representations of space underlying
behavior. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 5: 627-659.
Lucas, J. R. (1961) Minds, machines and Gödel. Philosophy 36: 112-117.
Lucas, M. M. & Hayes, P. J. (Eds.) (1982) Proceedings of the Cognitive
Curricula Conference. University of Rochester: Rochester NY
McClelland, J.L., Rumelhart, D. E., and the PDP Research Group (1986) Parallel
distributed processing: Explorations in the microstructure of cognition, Volume
1. Cambridge MA: MIT/Bradford.
McDermott, D. (1982) Minds, brains, programs and persons. Behavioral and
Brain Sciences 5: 339-341.
Minsky, M. & Papert, S. (1969) Perceptrons: An introduction to computational
geometry. Cambridge MA: MIT Press
Nagel, T. (1974) What is it like to be a bat? Philosophical Review 83: 435-451.
Nagel, T. (1986) The view from nowhere. New York: Oxford University Press.
Putnam, H. (1975) Mind, language and reality. New York: Cambridge University
Press.
Pylyshyn, Z. W. (1973) What the mind's eye tells the mind's brain: A critique of
mental imagery. Psychological Bulletin 80: 1-24.
Pylyshyn, Z. W. (1980) Computation and cognition: Issues in the foundations of
cognitive sciences. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3: 111-169.
Pylyshyn, Z. W. (1984) Computation and cognition. Cambridge
MA:MIT/Bradford.
Rey, G. (1986) What's really going on in Searle's "Chinese Room"? Philosophical
Studies 50: 169-185.
Rosenblatt, F. (1962) Principles of neurodynamics. Washington DC: Spartan. &
Rougeul-Buser (1978, 215 - 232).
Rumelhart, D. E., McClelland, J.L., and the PDP Research Group (1986) Parallel
distributed processing: Explorations in the microstructure of cognition, Volume
2. Cambridge MA: MIT/Bradford.
Russow, L.-M. (1984) Nature & System 6: 221-227.
Searle, J. R. (1980a) Minds, brains and programs. Behavioral and Brain Sciences
3: 417-424.
Searle, J. R. (1980b) Instrinsic intentionality. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 3:
450-457.
Searle, J. R. (1982a) The Chinese room revisited. Behavioral and Brain Sciences
5: 345-348.
Searle, J. R. (1982b) The myth of the computer. New York Review of Books
XXIX(7): 3-7.
Searle, J. R. (1982c) The myth of the computer: An exchange. New York Review
of Books XXIX(11): 56-57.
Searle, J. R. (1985a) Patterns, symbols and understanding. Behavioral and Brain
Sciences 8: 742-743.
Searle, J. R. (1985b) Minds, brains and science. Cambridge MA: Harvard
University Press.
Selverston, A. I. (1980) Are central pattern generators understandable? Behavioral
and Brain Sciences 3: 535-571.
Slezak, P. (1982) Goedel's theorem and the mind. British Journal for the
Philosophy of Science 33: 41-52.
Smolensky, P. (1988) On the proper treatment of connectionism. Behavioral and
Brain Sciences 11: 1-XX.
Steklis, H. D. & Harnad, S. R. (1976) From hand to mouth: Some critical stages in
the evolution of language. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 280:
445-455.
Turing, A. M. (1964) Computing machinery and intelligence. In: Minds and
machines, A. R. Anderson (ed.), Engelwood Cliffs NJ: Prentice Hall.
Wilensky, R. (1980) Computers, cognition and philosophy. Behavioral and Brain
Sciences 3: 449-450.
relation_type: []
relation_uri: []
reportno: ~
rev_number: 8
series: ~
source: ~
status_changed: 2007-09-12 16:38:45
subjects:
- cog-psy
- comp-sci-robot
- ling-sem
- phil-mind
succeeds: ~
suggestions: ~
sword_depositor: ~
sword_slug: ~
thesistype: ~
title: 'Minds, Machines and Searle'
type: journalp
userid: 63
volume: 1