creators_name: Thomas, Laurence type: preprint datestamp: 2003-11-24 lastmod: 2011-03-11 08:55:24 metadata_visibility: show title: Equality and the Mantra of Diversity subjects: phil-ethics full_text_status: public keywords: diversity, inferiority, idiosyncratic excellence, stigma abstract: This essay is part of a symposium on affirmative action that took place at the University of Cincinnati with the distinguished legal scholar Ronald Dworkin. I argue against affirmative action. And I discuss at length the votes of Justice Sandra Day O'Connor and the dissent of Justice Clarence Thomas. I develop the idea of idiosyncratic excellence; and I argue that diversity is a weakness insofar as it (a) an excuse for social myopia and (b)an impediment to individuals seeing beyond their differences and affirming the excellences that they witness. The expected publication date, Univ of Cinn Law Review, is March 2004. date: 2003-11 date_type: published refereed: FALSE referencetext: Lawrence Blum, I'm Not a Racist, But . . .: The Moral Quandry of Race (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2002) Ronald Dworkin, "The Court and the University," The New York Review of Books (15 May 2003) Ronald Dworkin, "Is Affirmative Action Doomed?," New York Review of Books (5 November 1998) Thomas Nagel, "Equal Treatment and Compensatory Discrimination," Philosophy and Public Affairs 2 (1973) Laurence Thomas, "Forgiving the Unforgivable," in Eve Garrard and Geoffrey Scarre (eds.) Moral Philosophy and the Holocaust (England: Ashgate Press, 2003) citation: Thomas, Laurence (2003) Equality and the Mantra of Diversity. [Preprint] document_url: http://cogprints.org/3280/1/Thomas_AffAction.pdf