TY - GEN ID - cogprints393 UR - http://cogprints.org/393/ A1 - Chow, Siu L. Y1 - 1992/// N2 - The rhetoric-analytic critique of experimental psychology owes its apparent attractiveness to (a) some erroneous ideas about cognitive psychology and the rationale of experimentation, (b) the failure to distinguish between prior data and evidential data vis-à-vis the to-be-corroborated explanatory theory, and (c) evidential data owes their identity to a theory that is independent of the theory being tested. Theories in cognitive psychology are accepted because they can withstand concerted efforts to falsify them. KW - Theory-dependent observation KW - Rhetoric KW - Objectivity KW - Theory corroboration KW - Rationale of experimentation KW - Data prior to the theory KW - Evidential data in support of the theory TI - Acceptance of a Theory: Justification or Rhetoric? SP - 447 AV - public EP - 474 ER -