Mark Twain Meets DSM-III-R: Conduct Disorder, Development, and the Concept of Harmful Dysfunction

Richters, John and Cicchetti, Dante (1993) Mark Twain Meets DSM-III-R: Conduct Disorder, Development, and the Concept of Harmful Dysfunction. [Journal (Paginated)]

Full text available as:

[img] PDF


The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (3rd ed., rev.) (DSM-III-R) diagnosis of conduct disorder assumes that all children who engage in three or more criterion antisocial behaviors for 6 months or more suffer from a mental disorder. It resists all contextual information about a child's developmental history, capacities, strengths and circumstances, and assumes that the antisocial behavior necessarily stems from an underlying disorder. In this review, we use Mark Twain's narrative of the lives of Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn as a point of departure for questioning the reasonableness of this assumption, and for examining normal as well as pathological pathways to antisocial behavior. We begin by reviewing the status of earlier controversies about the mental disorder concept in the service of documenting the impressive progress of the field in conceptualizing disorder. Next, we examine Wakefield's (1992a, 1992b) recently introduced 'harmful dysfunction' concept of mental disorder and employ its criteria to evaluate the hypothesis that chronic antisocial behavior in childhood as defined by DSM-III-R is caused by an underlying mental disorder. We also examine some of the difficulties in discriminating between disorder- and nondisorder-based antisocial behavior, and consider issues that warrant attention in future theoretical and empirical work. Finally, we explore the pragmatic rather than scientific basis for DSM-III-R's mental disorder claim and argue that regardless of its status as a mental dsorder, this most troubling and harmful behavior syndrome of childhood deserves the intensive interest, concern, and resources of the scientific and public health communities.

Item Type:Journal (Paginated)
Keywords:Mental Disorder, Psychopathology, Classification, Delinquency, Evolution, Violence, Childhood Antisocial Behavior
Subjects:Psychology > Clinical Psychology
Psychology > Developmental Psychology
ID Code:1024
Deposited By: Richters, John
Deposited On:16 Oct 2000
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:54

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Achenbach, T. M. (in this issue). Taxonomy and comorbidity of conduct problems: Evidence from empirically based approaches. Development and Psychopathology.

American Psychiatric Association (1980). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed.). Washington, D.C.: Author.

American Psychiatric Association (1987). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed., rev.). Washington, D.C.: Author.

Asarnow, J. R., & Callan, J. W. (1985). Boys with peer adjustment problems: Social cognitive processes. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 53, 80-87.

Ausubel, D. P. (1971). Personality disorder is disease. American Psychologist, 16, 59-74.

Becker, M.L. (1947). Introduction: How this book came to be written. In M. Twain, The adventures of Huckleberry Finn. Cleveland, OH: World Press.

Blackburn, R. (1988). On moral judgments and personality disorders: The myth of psychopathic personality revisited. British Journal of Psychiatry, 153, 505-512.

Bretherton, I. (1985). Attachment theory: Retrospect and Prospect. In I. Bretherton and E. Waters (Eds.), Growing points of attachment theory and research. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 50(1-2 Serial No. 209), 3-35.

Brown, G. L., Goodwin, F. K., Ballenger, J. C., Goyer, P. F., & Major, L. F. (1979). Aggression in humans correlates with cerebrospinal fluid amine metabolites. Psychiatry Research, 1, 131-139.

Buss, D. M. (1984). Evolutionary biology and personality psychology: Toward a conception of human nature and individual differences. American Psychologist, 39, 1135-1147.

Cairns, R. B., Cairns, B. D., & Neckerman, H. J. (1989). Early school dropout: Configurations and determinants. Child Development, 60, 1437-1452.

Campbell, S. B. (1991). Longitudinal studies of active and aggressive preschoolers: Individual differences in early behavior and in outcome. In D. Cicchetti & S. L. Toth (Eds.), Rochester Symposium on Developmental Psychopathology, Volume 2: Internalizing and externalizing expressions of dysfunction (pp. 57-89). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Campbell, S. B., Breaux, A. M., Ewing, L. J., & Szumowski, E. K. (1986). Correlates and prediction of hyperactivity and aggression: A longitudinal study of parent-referred problem preschoolers. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 14, 217-234.

Carson, R.C. (1991). Dilemmas in the pathway of the DSM-IV. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 100, 302-307.

Cartwright, S. A. (1981/1851). Report on the diseases and physical peculiarities of the human race. In A. L. Caplan, H. T. Egelhart, Jr., & J. J. McCartney (Eds.), Concepts of health and disease: International perspectives (pp. 305-326). Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.

Chamberlain, B., Ervin, F. R., Pihl, R. O., & Young, S. N. (1987). The effects of raising or lowering tryptophan levels on aggression in vervet monkeys. Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior, 28, 503-510.

Cicchetti, D. (1984). The Emergence of Developmental Psychopathology. Child Development, 55, 1-7.

Cicchetti, D. (1989). Developmental psychopathology: Some thoughts on its evolution. Development and Psychopathology, 1, 1-4.

Cicchetti, D. (1990). Perspectives on the interface between normal and atypical development. Development and Psychopathology, 2(4), 329-333.

Cicchetti, D. (1991). Fractures in the crystal: Developmental Psychopathology and the emergence of the self. Developmental Review, 11, 271-287.

Cicchetti, D., Ganiban, J., & Barnett, D. (1991). Contributions from the Study of High Risk Populations to Understanding the Development of Emotion Regulation. In J. Garber and K. Dodge (Eds.), The Development of Emotion Regulation and Dysregulation (pp 15-48). New York: Cambridge University Press.

Cicchetti, D. & Lynch, M. (in press). Toward an ecological/transactional model of community violence and child maltreatment: Consequences for children's development. Psychiatry.

Cicchetti, D. & Richters, J. E. (this issue). Developmental Considerations in the Investigation of Conduct Disorder. Development and Psychopathology.

Cicchetti, D., & Schneider-Rosen, K. (1986). An organizational approach to childhood depression. In M. Rutter, C. E. Izard, & P. B. Read (Eds.), Depression in young people: Developmental and clinical perspectives (pp. 71-134). New York: Guilford Press.

Cicchetti, D., & Toth, S.L. (1991). The Making of a Developmental Psychopathologist. In J. Cantor, C. Spiker, and L. Lipsitt (Eds.), Child Behavior and Development: Training for Diversity (pp. 34-72). Norwood, NJ: Ablex.

Cicchetti, D., Toth, S.L. & Bush, M. (1988). Developmental psychopathology and incompetence in childhood: Suggestions for intervention. In B. Lahey and A. Kazdin (Eds.) Advances in clinical child psychology, Vol. 11 (p 1-71). New York: Plenum.

Cocarro, E. F., Siever, L. J., Klar, H. M., Maurer, G., Cochrane, K., Cooper, T. B., Mohs, R. C., & Davis, K. L. (1989). Serotonergic studies in patients with affective and personality disorders: Correlates with suicidal and impulsive aggressive behavior. Archives of General Psychiatry, 46, 587-599.

Cicchetti, D., & Schneider-Rosen, K. (1986). An organizational approach to childhood depression. In M. Rutter, C. E. Izard, & P. B. Read (Eds.), Depression in young people: Developmental and clinical perspectives (pp. 71-134). New York: Guilford Press.

Cohen, H. (1981). The evolution of the concept of disease. In A. L. Caplan, H. T. Engelhardt, Jr., & J. J. McCartney (Eds), Concepts of health and disease: Interdisciplinary perspectives (pp. 209-220). Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.

Crittenden, P. (1990).Internal representational models of attachment relationships. Infant Mental Health Journal, 11, 259-277.

Cronbach, L. J., & Meehl, P. E. (1955). Construct validity in psychological tests. Psychological Bulletin, 52, 281-302.

Cummings, J., & Volkman, E. (1992). Goombata: The improbable rise and fall of John Gotti and his gang. New York: Avon Books.

Daugherty, T. K., & Quay, H. C. (1991). Response perseveration and delayed responding in childhood behavior disorders. Journal of Child Psychiatry and Psychology, 32, 453-461.

Dawkins, R. (1976). The selfish gene. Oxford: Oxford University press.

Dishion, T. J., & Loeber, R. (1985). Adolescent marijuana and alcohol use: the role of parents and peers revisited. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 11, 11-15.

Dishion, T. J., Patterson, G. R., & Skinner, M. S. (1989, April). A process model for the role of peers in adolescent social adjustment. Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Kansas City, MO.

Dodge, K. A., Bates, J., & Pettit, G. S. (1990). Mechanisms in the cycle of violence. Science, 250, 1678-1683.

Dodge, K. A., Coie, J. D., Pettit, G. S., & Price, J. M. (1990). Peer status and aggression in boys' groups: Developmental and contextual analyses. Child Development, 61, 1289-1309.

Dodge, K. A., Murphy, R. R., & Buchsbaum, K. (1984). The assessment of intention-cue detection skills in children: Implications for developmental psychopathology. Child Development, 55, 163-173.

Dodge, K. A., Pettit, G. S., McClaskey, C. L., & Brown, M. (1986). Social competence in children: Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development (Serial No. 213, Vol. 51, No. 2).

Faraone, S. V., Biederman, J., Keenan, K., & Tsuang, M. T. (1991). Separation of DSM-III attention deficit disorder and conduct disorder: Evidence from a family genetic study of American child psychiatry patients. Psychological Medicine, 21, 109-121.

Farrington, D. P. (in this issue). Motivations for conduct disorder and delinquency. Development and Psychopathology.

Fingerhut, L.A., & Kleinman, J.C. (1990). International and interstate comparisons of homicide among young males. Journal of the American Medical Association, 263,3292-3295.

Foucault, M. (1978). History of sexuality: Vol. 1. An introduction. New York: Pantheon.

Garmezy, N. (1978). Never mind the psychologists: Is it good for the children? The Clinical Psychologist, 31, (3-4), 1-6.

Greenberg, M. T., Speltz, M. L., & DeKlyen, M. (in this issue). The role of attachment in the early development of disruptive behavior problems. Development and Psychopathology.

Higley, J. D., Mehlman, P. T., Taub, D. M., Higley, S. B., Suomi, S. J., Linnoila, M., & Vickers, J. H. (1992) Cerebrospinal fluid monoamine and adrenal correlates of aggression in free-ranging rhesus monkeys. Archives of General Psychiatry, 49, 436-441.

Hinshaw, S. (1987). On the distinction between attentional deficits/hyperactivity and conduct problems/aggression in child psychopathology. Psychological Bulletin, 101, 443-463.

Hinshaw, S. P., Lahey, B. B., & Hart, E. L. (this issue). Issues of taxonomy and comorbidity in the development of conduct disorder. Development and Psychopathology.

Hutschnecker, A. (1969). A plan for prevention of crime. Memo to the President of the United States on the Eisenhower Commission on Crime.

Institute of Medicine (1989). Research on Children and Adolescents with Mental, Behavioral, and Developmental Disorders. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press.

Jampala, V., Sierles, F., & Taylor, M. (1988). The use of DSM-III-R in the United States: A case of not going by the book. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 29, 39-47.

Kagan, J. (1984). The nature of the child. New York: Basic Books, Inc.

Kaler, S. R., & Kopp, C. B. (1990). Compliance and comprehension in very young toddlers. Child Development, 61, 1997-2003.

Kendell, R. E. (1975). The concept of disease and its implications for psychiatry. British Journal of Psychiatry, 127, 305-315.

Klein, D. F. (1978). A proposed definition of mental illness. In R. L. Spitzer & D. F. Klein (Eds). Critical issues in psychiatric diagnosis (pp. 41-71). New York: Raven Press.

Kruesi, M. J. P., Hibbs, E. D., Zahn, T. P., Keysor, C. S., Hamburger, S. D., Bartko, J. J., & Rapoport, J. L. (1992). A two-year prospective follow-up study of children and adolescents with disruptive behavior disorders: prediction by cerebrospinal fluid 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid, homovanillic acid, and autonomic measures. Archives of General Psychiatry, 49, 429-435.

Kruesi, M. J. P., Rapoport, J. L., Hamburger, S. D., Hibbs, E. D., Potter, W. Z., Lenare, M., & Brown, G. L. (1990). Cerebrospinal fluid monoamine metabolites, aggression, and impulsivity in disruptive behavior disorders of children and adolescents. Archives of General Psychiatry, 47, 419-426.

Ladd, G. S., Price, J. M., & Hart, C. H. (1990). Preschooler's behavioral orientations and patterns of peer control: Predictive of peer status? In S. R. Asher & J. D. Coie (Eds.), Peer rejection in childhood (pp. 90-115). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Laing, R. D. (1967). The politics of experience. London: Penguin Books.

Lahey, B. B., McBurnett, K., Loeber, R., & Hart, E. L. (in press). Psychobiology of conduct disorder. In G. P. Sholevar (Ed.), Conduct disorders in children and adolescents: Assessments and interventions. American Psychiatric Press.

Lochman, J. E. (1987). Self and peer perceptions and attributional biases of aggressive and non-aggressive boys in dyadic interactions. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 55, 404-410.

Loeber, R. (1988). Natural histories of conduct problems, delinquency, and associated substance use: Evidence for developmental progressions. In B. B. Lahey & A. E. Kazdin (Eds), Advances in clinical child psychology (Vol. 11, pp. 73-124). New York: Plenum Press.

Loeber, R., & Dishion, T. J. (1983). Early predictors of male delinquency: A review. Psychological Bulletin, 74, 68-99.

Loeber, R. & Stouthamer-Loeber, M. (1987). Prediction. In H. C. Quay (Ed)., Handbook of juvenile delinquency (pp. 325-382). New York: Wiley.

Loney, J. (1987). Hyperactivity and aggression in the diagnosis of attention deficit disorder. In B. B. Lahey & A. Kazdin (Eds), Advances in clinical child psychology (Vol. 10, pp. 99-135). New York: Plenum Press.

Lynch, M. & Cicchetti, D. (1991). Patterns of relatedness in maltreated and nonmaltreated children: Connections among multiple representational models. Development and Psychopathology, 3, 19-30.

McCord, J. (this issue). Conduct disorder and antisocial behavior: Some thoughts about processes. Development and Psychopathology

Meehl, P.E. (1973/1959). Some ruminations on the validation of clinical procedures. In P. E. Meehl (Ed.), Psychodiagnosis: Selected Papers (pp. 90-116). Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

Meltzer, L. J., Levine, M. D., Karniski, W., Palfreg, J. S., & Clarke, S. (1984). An analysis of the learning style of adolescent delinquents. Journal of Learning disabilities, 17, 600-608.

Moffitt, T. E. (1990a). Juvenile delinquency and attention-deficit disorder: Developmental trajectories from age 3 to 15. Child Development, 61, 893-910.

Moffitt, T. E. (1990b). The neuropsychology of delinquency: A critical review of theory and research. In N. Morris & M. Tonry (Eds). Crime and justice (Vol. 12, pp. 99-169). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago press.

Moffitt, T. E. (1992). Adolescent-limited versus life-course persistent delinquency. Unpubliched manuscript: University of Wisconsin, madison.

Moffitt, T. E. (in this issue). The neuropsychology of conduct disorder. Development and Psychopathology.

Moffitt, T. E., & Silva, P. A. (1988). IQ and delinquency: A direct test of the differential detection hypothesis. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 97, 330-333.

Morey, L. & Ochoa, E. (1989). An investigation of adherence to diagnostic criteria: Clinical diagnosis of the DSM-III-R personality diagnosis. Journal of Personality Disorders, 3, 180-192.

National Institute of Mental Health (1993). Request For Applications: Cooperative Agreement for Epidemiological Research into Child and Adolescent Mental Disorders. Author.

Newman, J. P. (1987). Reaction to punishment in extroverts and psychopaths: Implications for the impulsive behavior of disinhibited individuals. Journal of Research in Personality, 21, 464-480.

Newman, J. P., & Howland, E. (1989). The effect of incentives on Wisconsin card Sorting Task performance in psychopaths. Unpublished manuscript, University of Wisconsin at Madison.

Newman, J. P., & Kosson, D. S. (1986). Passive avoidance learning in psychopathic and nonpsychopathic offenders. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 95, 257-263.

Oldham, P. D., Pickering, G., Fraser Roberts, J. A., & Sowry, G. S. C. (1960). The nature of essential hypertension. Lancet, ii, 877-882.

Patterson, G. R., Capaldi, D., & Bank, L. (1991). An early starter model for predicting delinquency. In D. Pepler & K. H. Rubin (Eds.), The development and treatment of childhood aggression (pp. 139-168). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Pennington, B. F., & Bennetto, L. (this issue). Main effects or transactions in the neuropsychology of conduct disorder? Development and Psychopathology.

Pileggi, N. (1985). Wiseguy: Life in a mafia family. New york: Pocket Books.

Quay, H. C. (this issue). The psychobiology of undersocialized aggressive conduct disorder: A theoretical perspective. Development and Psychopathology.

Radke-Yarrow, M. & Zahn-Waxler, C. (1990). Research on children of affectively ill parents: Some considerations for theory and research on normal development. Development and Psychopathology, 2, 349-366.

Raine, A., & Venables, P. H. (1984). Electrodermal non-responding, antisocial behavior and schizoid tendencies in adolescents. Psychophysiology, 21, 424-433.

Raine, A., Venables, P. H., & Williams, M. A. (1990). Autonomic orienting responses in 15-year-old male subjects and criminal behavior at age 24. American Journal of Psychiatry, 147, 933-937.

Raliegh, M. J., Brammer, G. L., Ritvo, E. R., Geller, E., McGuire, M. T., & Yuwiler, A. (1986). Effects of chronic fenfluramine on blood serotonin, cerebrospinal fluid metabolites, and behavior in monkeys. Psychopharmacology, 90, 503-508.

Richters, J. E. (1993). Community violence and children's development: Toward a research agenda for the 1990's. Psychiatry, 56, 3-6.

Richters, J. E., & Cicchetti, D. (this issue). Editorial: Toward a developmental perspective on conduct disorder. Development and Psychopathology.

Richters, J. E. & Martinez, P. (1993). The NIMH Community Violence Project: Children as Victims and Witnesses to Violence. Psychiatry, 56, 7-21.

Richters, J. E. & Waters, E. (1991). Attachment and socialization: The positive side of social influence. In M. Lewis & S. Feinman (Eds.), Social influences and socialization in infancy (185-213). New York: Plenum Publishing Company.

Robins, L. N. (1966). Deviant children grown up. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.

Robins, L. N. & Regier, D. A. (1991). Psychiatric disorders in America: The Epidemiological Catchment Area Study. New York: The Free Press.

Rotenberg, M. (1978). Psychopathy and differential insensitivity. In R. Hare & D. Schalling (Eds.), Psychopathic behavior. New York: Wiley.

Rourke, B. P. (1985). Statistical analysis of large neuropsychological data bases: Methodological and clinical considerations. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 7, 631.

Rutter, M. (1986). Child psychiatry: The interface between clinical and developmental research. Psychological Medicine, 16, 151-160.

Sarbin, T. (1967). On the futility of the proposition that some people be labeled 'mentally ill'. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 31, 447-453.

Shapiro, S. K., Quay, H. C., Hogan, A. E., & Schwartz, K. P. (1988). Response perseveration and delayed responding in undersocialized aggressive conduct disorder. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 97, 371-373.

Spitzer, R. L., Sheehy, M., & Endicott, J. (1977). Guiding principles. In V.M. Rakoff, H. C. Staneer, & H.B. Keeward (Eds.), Psychiatric diagnosis (pp. 1-24). New York: Bruner/Mazel.

Sroufe, L. A., & Rutter, M. (1984). The domain of developmental psychopathology. Child Development, 55, 17-29.

Susman, E. J. (in this issue). Psychological, Contextual, and Psychobiological Interactions: A Developmental Perspective on Conduct Disorder. Development and Psychopathology.

Szasz, T. S. (1960). The myth of mental illness: Foundations of a theory of personal conduct. New York: Harper & Row.

Szasz, T. S. (1971). The sane slave. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 25, 228-239.

Taylor, V. A. (1989). The vote on DSM-IV. Archives of General Psychiatry, 46, 959.

Twain, M. (1876/1950). The adventures of Tom Sawyer. Middlesex, England: Penguin Books, Ltd.

Twain, M. (1947). The adventures of Huckleberry Finn. Cleveland, Ohio: World Publishing.

Wakefield, J. C. (1992a). Disorder as harmful dysfunction: A conceptual critique of DSM-III-R's definition of mental disorder. Psychological Review, 99, 232-247.

Wakefield, J. C. (1992b). The concept of mental disorder: On the boundary between biological facts and social values. American Psychologist, 47, 373-388.

Walker, J. L., Lahey, B. B., Russo, M. F., Christ, M. A. G., McBurnett, K., Loeber, R., Stouthamer-Loeber, M., & Green, S. M. (1991). Anxiety, inhibition, and conduct disorder in children: Relations to social impairment. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 30, 187-191.

Washington Post (1970, April 10). Dr. Hutschnecker's modest proposal. Washington Post, p. A18.

Waters, E., Vaughn, B., & Egeland, B. (1980). Individual differences in infant-mother attachment. Antecedents in neonatal behavior in an urban economically disadvantaged sample. Child Development, 51, 208-216.

White, J., Moffitt, T. E., Caspi, A., Needles, D. J., & Stouthamer-Loeber, M. (in press). Measuring impulsivity and examining its relationship to delinquency. In G. P. Sholeva (Ed.), Conduct disorders in children and adolescents: Assessments on intervention. Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Press.

Wilson, M. (1993). DSM-III and the transformation of American psychiatry: A history. American Journal of Psychiatry, 150, 399-410.

Zoccolillo, M. (1992). Co-occurrence of conduct disorder and its adult outcomes with depressive and anxiety disorders: A review. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 31, 547-556.

Zoccolillo, M., Pickles, A., Quinton, D., & Rutter, M. (1992). The outcome of childhood conduct disorder: Implications for defining adult personality disorder. Psychological Medicine, 22, 000-000

.Zubin, J. (1978). But is it good for science? Clinical Psychologist, 31, (2), 1-7.

Zubin, J., & Spring, B. (1977). Vulnerability -- a new view of schizophrenia. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 86, 103-126.


Repository Staff Only: item control page