Blind man’s bluff and the Turing test

Clifton, Mr Andrew (2004) Blind man’s bluff and the Turing test. [Preprint]

Full text available as:



It seems plausible that under the conditions of the Turing test, congenitally blind people could nevertheless, with sufficient preparation, successfully represent themselves to remotely located interrogators as sighted. Having never experienced normal visual sensations, the successful blind player can prevail in this test only by playing a ‘lying game’—imitating the phenomenological claims of sighted people, in the absence of the qualitative visual experiences to which such statements purportedly refer. This suggests that a computer or robot might pass the Turing test in the same way, in the absence not only of visual experience, but qualitative consciousness in general. Hence, the standard Turing test does not provide a valid criterion for the presence of consciousness. A ‘sensorimetric’ version of the Turing test fares no better, for the apparent correlations we observe between cognitive functions and qualitative conscious experiences seems to be contingent, not necessary. We must therefore define consciousness not in terms of its causes and effects, but rather, in terms of the distinctive properties of its content, such as its possession of qualitative character and apparent intrinsic value—the property which confers upon consciousness its moral significance. As a means of determining whether or nor a machine is conscious, in this sense, an alternative to the standard Turing test is proposed.

Item Type:Preprint
Keywords:Artificial intelligence, consciousness, functionalism, phenomenal qualities, qualia, Turing test
Subjects:Computer Science > Machine Vision
Philosophy > Philosophy of Mind
Computer Science > Artificial Intelligence
ID Code:3480
Deposited By: Clifton, Mr Andrew
Deposited On:07 Mar 2004
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:55

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Clifton, A. (2003) [a] ‘An empirical case against materialism.’ Unpublished MS.

Clifton, A. (2004) [b] ‘The introspection game – or, does the Tin Man have a heart.’ Unpublished MS.

Clifton, A. (2004) [c] ‘The hazards of silicon heaven.’ Unpublished MS.

Clifton, A. (2004) [d] ‘Res cogitans.’ Unpublished MS.

Turing, A. (1950) ‘Computing machinery and intelligence.’ Mind 59: 443-460.


Repository Staff Only: item control page