Myths and Legends of the Baldwin Effect

Turney, Peter (1996) Myths and Legends of the Baldwin Effect. [Conference Paper]

Full text available as:



This position paper argues that the Baldwin effect is widely misunderstood by the evolutionary computation community. The misunderstandings appear to fall into two general categories. Firstly, it is commonly believed that the Baldwin effect is concerned with the synergy that results when there is an evolving population of learning individuals. This is only half of the story. The full story is more complicated and more interesting. The Baldwin effect is concerned with the costs and benefits of lifetime learning by individuals in an evolving population. Several researchers have focussed exclusively on the benefits, but there is much to be gained from attention to the costs. This paper explains the two sides of the story and enumerates ten of the costs and benefits of lifetime learning by individuals in an evolving population. Secondly, there is a cluster of misunderstandings about the relationship between the Baldwin effect and Lamarckian inheritance of acquired characteristics. The Baldwin effect is not Lamarckian. A Lamarckian algorithm is not better for most evolutionary computing problems than a Baldwinian algorithm. Finally, Lamarckian inheritance is not a better model of memetic (cultural) evolution than the Baldwin effect.

Item Type:Conference Paper
Subjects:Computer Science > Machine Learning
Biology > Evolution
ID Code:2889
Deposited By: Turney, Peter
Deposited On:16 Apr 2003
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:55

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Ackley, D., and Littman, M. (1991). Interactions between learning and

evolution. In Proceedings of the Second Conference on Artificial Life, C.

Langton, C. Taylor, D. Farmer, and S. Rasmussen, editors. California:


Anderson, R.W. (1995a). Learning and evolution: A quantitative genetics

approach. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 175, 89-101.

Anderson, R.W. (1995b). Genetic mechanisms underlying the Baldwin

effect are evident in natural antibodies. In Evolutionary Programming IV:

The Edited Proceedings of the Fourth Annual Conference on Evolutionary

Programming, edited by J.R. McDonnell, R.G. Reynolds, and D.B.

Fogel, pp. 547-563. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Balakrishnan, K., and Honavar, V. (1995). Evolutionary design of neural

architectures: A preliminary taxonomy and guide to literature. Artificial

Intelligence Research Group, Department of Computer Science, Iowa

State University, Technical Report CS TR #95-01.

Baldwin, J.M. (1896). A new factor in evolution. American Naturalist,

30, 441-451.

Barkow, J.H., Cosmides, L., and Tooby, J. (1992). Editors, The Adapted

Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture, New

York: Oxford University Press.

Behera, N., and Nanjundiah, V. (1995). An investigation into the role of

phenotypic plasticity in evolution. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 172,


Belew, R.K. (1989). When both individuals and populations search:

Adding simple learning to the Genetic Algorithm. In Proceedings of the

Third International Conference on Genetic Algorithms, 34-41, Washington


Belew, R.K. (1990). Evolution, learning and culture: computational

metaphors for adaptive search. Complex Systems, 4, 11-49.

Belew, R.K., McInerney, J., and Schraudolph, N.N. (1991). Evolving

networks: Using the Genetic Algorithm with connectionist learning. In

Proceedings of the Second Artificial Life Conference, 511-547, Addison-


Belew, R.K. and Mitchell, M., (1996). Editors, Adaptive Individuals in

Evolving Populations: Models and Algorithms, Massachusetts: Addison-


Burke, E.K., Newall, J.P., and Weare, R.F. (1995). A memetic algorithm

for university exam timetabling. Proceedings of the First International

Conference on the Practice and Theory of Automated Timetabling

(ICPTAT-95), 496-503. Napier University, Edinburgh.

Cecconi, F., Menczer, F., and Belew, R.K. (1995). Maturation and the

evolution of imitative learning in artificial organisms. Technical Report

CSE 506, University of California, San Diego, 1995; to appear in

Adaptive Behavior, 4, January 1996.

Cziko, G. (1995). Without Miracles: Universal Selection Theory and the

Second Darwinian Revolution. Massachusetts: MIT Press.

Dawkins, R. (1976). The Selfish Gene. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Dawkins, R. (1982). The Extended Phenotype: The Gene as the Unit of

Natural Selection. San Francisco: Freeman.

French, R., and Messinger, A. (1994). Genes, phenes and the Baldwin

effect. In Rodney Brooks and Patricia Maes (editors), Artificial Life IV.

Cambridge MA: MIT Press.

Gottlieb, G. (1992). Evolution: The modern synthesis and its failure to

incorporate individual development into evolutionary theory. Chapter 11

of Individual Development and Evolution: The Genesis of Novel

Behavior. New York: Oxford University Press.

Gould, (1991). Bully for Brontosaurus: Reflections in Natural History.

New York: Norton.

Hart, W.E. (1994). Adaptive Global Optimization with Local Search.

Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Computer Science and Engineering, University

of California, San Diego.

Hart, W.E., and Belew, R.K. (1996). Optimization with genetic algorithm

hybrids that use local search. In R.K. Belew and M. Mitchell, (editors),

Adaptive Individuals in Evolving Populations: Models and Algorithms,


Hart, W.E., Kammeyer, T.E., and Belew, R.K. (1995). The role of development

in genetic algorithms. In L.D. Whitley and M.D. Vose, (editors),

Foundations of Genetic Algorithms 3, California: Morgan Kaufmann.

Harvey, I. (1993). The puzzle of the persistent question marks: A case

study of genetic drift. In S. Forrest (editor) Proceedings of the Fifth International

Conference on Genetic Algorithms, ICGA-93, California:

Morgan Kaufmann.

Haussler, D. (1988). Quantifying inductive bias: AI learning algorithms

and Valiant’s learning framework. Artificial Intelligence, 36, 177-221.

Hightower, R., Forrest, S., and Perelson, A. (1996) The Baldwin effect in

the immune system: learning by somatic hypermutation. In R.K. Belew

and M. Mitchell, (editors), Adaptive Individuals in Evolving Populations:

Models and Algorithms, Addison-Wesley.

Hinton, G.E., and Nowlan, S.J. (1987). How learning can guide evolution.

Complex Systems, 1, 495-502.

Maynard Smith, J. (1987). When learning guides evolution. Nature, 329,


Menczer, F., and Belew, R.K. (1994). Evolving sensors in environments

of controlled complexity. In R. Brooks and P. Maes, (editors), Artificial

Life IV, MIT Press.

Morgan, C.L. (1896). On modification and variation. Science, 4, 733-


Moscato, P. (1989). On evolution, search, optimization, genetic algorithms

and martial arts: Towards memetic algorithms. Technical Report

826, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California.

Moscato, P. (1993). An introduction to population approaches for optimization

and hierarchical objective functions: The role of tabu search.

Annals of Operations Research, 41, 85-121.

Moscato, P., and Fontanari, J.F. (1990). Stochastic versus deterministic

update in simulated annealing. Physics Letters A, 146, 204-208.

Moscato, P. and Norman, M.G. (1992). A memetic approach for the travelling

salesman problem. In Proceedings of the International Conference

on Parallel Computing and Transputer Applications, 177-186. Amsterdam:

IOS Press.

Nolfi, S., Elman, J.L., and Parisi, D. (1994). Learning and evolution in

neural networks, Adaptive Behavior, 3, 5-28.

Norman, M.G., and Moscato, P. (1989). A competitive-cooperative

approach to complex combinatorial search. In Selected Work for the Proceedings

of the 20th Joint Conference on Informatics and Operations

Research, 3.15-3.29, Buenos Aires, Argentina.

Osborn, H.F. (1896). Ontogenic and phylogenic variation. Science, 4,


Paechter, B., Cumming, A., Norman, M.G., and Luchian, H. (1995).

Extensions to a memetic timetabling system. Proceedings of the First

International Conference on the Practice and Theory of Automated Timetabling

(ICPTAT-95), 455-467. Napier University, Edinburgh.

Pinker, S. (1994). The Language Instinct: How the Mind Creates

Language, New York: William Morrow and Co.

Radcliffe, N.J., and Surry, P.D., (1994). Formal memetic algorithms. Proceedings

of the AISB Workshop on Evolutionary Computing. Berlin:


Rendell, L. (1986). A general framework for induction and a study of

selective induction. Machine Learning, 1, 177-226.

Scheiner, S. (1993). Genetics and evolution of phenotypic plasticity.

Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 24, 35-68.

Simpson, G.C. (1953). The Baldwin effect. Evolution, 7, 110-117.

Sober, E. (1994) The adaptive advantage of learning and a priori prejudice.

In From a Biological Point of View: Essays in Evolutionary Philosophy,

a collection of essays by E. Sober, 50-70, Cambridge University


Turney, P.D. (1995). Cost-sensitive classification: Empirical evaluation

of a hybrid genetic decision tree induction algorithm. Journal for AI

Research, 2, 369-409.

Unemi, T., Nagayoshi, M., Hirayama, N., Nade, T., Yano, K., and

Masujima, Y. (1994). Evolutionary differentiation of learning abilities - a

case study on optimizing parameter values in Q-learning by a genetic

algorithm, In Rodney Brooks and Patricia Maes (editors), Artificial Life

IV. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.

Utgoff, P. (1986). Shift of bias for inductive concept learning. In Machine

Learning: An Artificial Intelligence Approach, Volume II. Edited by R.S.

Michalski, J.G. Carbonell, and T.M. Mitchell. California: Morgan


Waddington, C.H. (1942). Canalization of development and the inheritance

of acquired characters. Nature, 150, 563-565.

Wcislo, W.T. (1989). Behavioral environments and evolutionary change.

Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 20, 137-169.

West-Eberhard, M. (1989). Phenotypic plasticity and the origins of diversity.

Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 20, 249-278.

Whitley, D., and Gruau, F. (1993). Adding learning to the cellular development

of neural networks: Evolution and the Baldwin effect. Evolutionary

Computation, 1, 213-233.

Whitley, D., Gordon, S., and Mathias, K. (1994). Lamarckian evolution,

the Baldwin effect and function optimization. Parallel Problem Solving

from Nature - PPSN III. In Y. Davidor, H.P. Schwefel, and R. Manner,

editors, pp. 6-15. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.


Repository Staff Only: item control page